Blog
What to Do If You Inherit a House
Lee Blackburn
So what should you actually do when you inherit a house?
Inheriting a home can feel like both a major opportunity and a big responsibility. When you inherit the home from someone you loved, there are memories attached to the property. And now, you’re faced with practical decisions that can affect your finances and your future.
The answer to your what-to-do question depends on your goals, your current circumstances, and the condition of the property itself. As property managers, we’ve worked with a number of people in this situation, and we think a fresh look at how to approach the decision thoughtfully and strategically might help you to reach the right conclusion.
Quick Summary:
|
You Have to Start with the Legal and Financial Basics
Before making any big plans, confirm that the home is legally yours.
That may mean going through probate or filing the proper paperwork to transfer the deed into your name. If there are multiple heirs, you’ll need to clarify who owns what and how decisions will be made. A probate attorney can help ensure everything is handled properly and that there are no surprises down the road.
At this point, you’ll also need to review the financial obligations tied to the home:
- Is there an existing mortgage?
- Are property taxes current?
- Are there liens against the property?
- Does the home belong to an HOA with outstanding dues?
If a mortgage remains, you may be able to continue making payments. Confirm this with the lender so you understand your responsibilities. Getting organized at this stage prevents complications when you’re trying to do other things with the property.
Deciding to Keep It, Rent It, Sell It, or Decline It
Once you understand the logistics, you have several options when it comes to what you should do with this property.
- Move Into the Home
If the property suits your lifestyle or location needs, living in it may make sense. This can provide stability and eliminate your current housing costs. However, you’ll still be responsible for maintenance, taxes, insurance, and any repairs.
- Turn It Into a Rental
Many heirs choose to keep the home as an investment. Renting it out can create steady income and long-term wealth. This option works best if the property is in a desirable rental area and you’re comfortable treating it as a business. You’ll need to be prepared for ongoing maintenance and tenant management.
If you don’t want to manage it yourself, a professional property management company can handle leasing, maintenance coordination, and rent collection. This can be a huge help to owners who are happy to have the asset but unwilling to collect rent and enforce lease agreements.
- Sell the Property
Selling provides immediate liquidity and eliminates ongoing responsibilities. Maybe there are other things you’d like to do with the money that is in the home. Before listing, consider whether minor repairs or updates could increase the sale price. Think about tax exposure, too.
- Disclaim the Inheritance
You don’t have to take the property. If the property comes with heavy debt, complicated co-ownership issues, or responsibilities you don’t want, you may legally decline the inheritance. This decision should be discussed with a financial or legal professional before taking action.
Evaluate the Condition of the Home
No matter which direction you’re leaning, get a clear picture of the property’s condition.
A professional inspection can identify structural issues, outdated systems, or hidden problems that may affect your decision. Knowing what repairs are needed helps you:
- Budget realistically
- Set an appropriate listing price
- Determine market readiness (rental or sales market)
- Avoid costly surprises
If you plan to rent the home, updates like fresh paint, modern fixtures, or safety upgrades can increase rental value and attract stronger tenants.
Run the Numbers Carefully
If you’re going to sell, make sure the market supports the asking price that you plan. If you’re considering renting the property, treat it like an investment from day one.
- Estimate Rental Income. Research similar homes in the same neighborhood to determine what the property could reasonably rent for. Rental markets are hyper-local, so focus on comparable homes nearby.
- Calculate Expenses. Typical costs may include mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, repairs and maintenance, property management fees, and vacancy allowance (plan for at least 1–2 months per year).
Subtract expenses from projected rent to estimate potential cash flow. If the home is fully paid off, your margin may be stronger, but you’ll still want reserves for maintenance and unexpected repairs.
Think Long-Term
Selling the home means you make money from it one time. Keeping and renting an inherited property can provide more than just monthly income. It can be a foundation for building wealth over time.
Key advantages include:
- Appreciation. Real estate often increases in value, especially in strong markets.
- Equity Growth. If there’s a mortgage, tenants help pay it down.
- Tax Benefits. Rental property owners may deduct certain expenses, including maintenance, property taxes, insurance, and depreciation.
- Increasing Cash Flow. As rents rise and costs stabilize, profitability can improve.
Over time, you could refinance, tap into equity, or even expand into additional investments.
Make the Decision That Fits Your Life
There’s no universal “right” answer when you inherit a house. The best choice depends on your financial situation and your long-term goals. You also want to think about your tolerance for responsibility and the property’s condition and location. Will it sell better or rent better?
What begins as an unexpected responsibility can become a meaningful opportunity, whether that’s financial freedom, a new residence, or a clean break with added liquidity.
If you’ve inherited a home and you’re not sure what to do with it, let’s talk about your specifics. Contact us at Omni Realtors & Property Management. We can help you sell it or rent it out to qualified tenants.